The Librarians: The Next Chapter Episode 11 Review - A Fantastic One-Off Idea Struggles Against A Busy, Tonally Dissonant Script
Warning: SPOILERS for The Librarians: The Next Chapter season 1, episode 11, "And the Graffiti of the Gods." Despite the spinoff’s many departures from the original series, The Librarians: The Next Chapter episode 11 presents a return to form with an amazing one-off episode idea that unfortunately gets buried under a jam-packed plot. With only one more episode before the wait for The Librarians: The Next Chapter season 2, it’s unfortunate timing for such a problem to arise. For the most part, “And the Graffiti of the Gods” gives everyone in The Librarians: The Next Chapter cast a chance to shine, including one of the most interesting episode-specific characters to appear in the spinoff thus far. But, while aspects of the story mimic The Librarians’ best episodes, the spinoff still needs to work on finding an appropriate tonal balance.
The Librarians: The Next Chapter Episode 11 Would Have Worked Better As A One-Off Episode
Its Ties To The Overarching Story Often Feel Forced
Coming off The Librarians: The Next Chapter episode 10, it very much feels as if this would have been the perfect time for the series to deliver a fun, self-contained, “threat of the week” episode. There have been several episodes in a row with major story beats setting up the season finale, and a brief reprieve could have been enjoyable. “And the Graffiti of the Gods” feels like it was tailor-made to deliver such an experience. The episode follows Hermione, a young woman from Portland, after she moves to Serbia and begins finding herself surrounded by menacing figures brought to life from paintings. As in many traditional The Librarians episodes, the main conflict becomes finding the source of the magic.
Related
The Return Of This OG Librarians TV Character Just Set Up A Shocking Next Chapter Season 2 Reveal
The Librarians: The Next Chapter just brought back an original character whose return could lead to a wild character reveal in season 2.
Unfortunately, there’s relatively little attention given to this conflict. Because the episode also needs to set up Gregor’s return for the finale, Hermione’s story is shoehorned into the story of Winslow Lynch and his band trying to bring back their cult leader. The episode does tie these plotlines together, but off-balance pacing makes them feel out of sync. This would be less upsetting if Hermione’s storyline weren’t so rife for further exploration, but what could have been a fun adventure about living artwork is largely replaced by a grim villain plot. This is accentuated by the fact that all whimsy is officially gone from Winslow’s band, and they aren’t the only victims of this episode’s attempted balancing act.
Hermione Is One Of The Librarians: The Next Chapter’s Most Interesting One-Off Characters
Although She Does Leave Her Story Open For Revisiting
It’s particularly disappointing that the episode splits Hermione’s storyline with Winslow’s because Hermione is one of the most compelling single-episode characters in The Librarians: The Next Chapter thus far. Not only does she face an interesting conflict, but she’s also given a backstory that could have sparkled with even a few more minutes of screentime to explore it more deeply. Hermione’s family has seen magical occurrences before. There’s even a subtle clue about her family’s past hidden in plain sight when looking at her grandmother’s wardrobe, although most viewers may not catch her attire’s relevance until it’s explained.
Related
The Librarians: The Next Chapter Episode 9’s Villain Sets Up One Character's Perfect Season 2 Frenemy
The Librarians: The Next Chapter episode 9 just introduced a character who could become the series’ best villain (and also greatest ally).
Even Hermione’s move from Portland to Belgrade adds intrigue to her character. It adds geographical diversity to her backstory, and also mirrors the shift from The Librarians filming in Oregon to The Next Chapter filming in Serbia. The episode doesn’t make a big deal of this, but it’s a cute treat for fans. Fortunately, while Hermione feels a bit robbed of the spotlight by Winslow’s plotline, episode 11 might not be her last appearance. Like Ivan Van Helsing in The Librarians: The Next Chapter episode 9, Hermione’s ending leaves the door wide open for her to meet with Vikram and company again. Hopefully, the episode’s other issues won’t hamper interest in her return.
Tonal Dissonance Is The Librarians: The Next Chapter Episode 11’s Biggest Obstacle
It Feels Like The Episode Is Trying To Be Three Things At Once
Tone is one of the major differences between The Librarians’ Flynn and Vikram, in the sense that Vikram’s emotions don’t always necessarily match the gravity of the scene as well as Flynn’s typically do. But, while that works for The Next Chapter after spending 11 episodes with Vikram, this entire episode can’t seem to find the tonal balance it wants. Whatever humor Winslow and his metal band provided in past episodes is completely out the window in episode 11. Unfortunately, the episode’s living art premise is treated with a sense of whimsical fantasy that doesn’t match the darker tone of the Gregor’s Hammer subplot. This leads to many scenes feeling incredibly (and often uncomfortably) disjointed from one another. In an unusual twist (yet a fitting one when considering the episode’s premise), this tonal imbalance can be seen in the visual effects, which are also relatively lacking in consistency. For most of the episode, artwork brought to life is depicted realistically, but the episode randomly switches to a cartoon aesthetic in the final scenes for a Roger Rabbit-style ending.
Related
Charlie's New Side In The Librarians: The Next Chapter Season 2 Previewed By Star: "I Love Getting To Play That"
EXCLUSIVE: The Librarians: The Next Chapter star Jessica Green has opened up on the exciting new side to her character Charlie in season 2.
The best example of how this affects the tone can be seen in Connor’s last action beat. After climbing tall structures in seemingly every other episode, Connor’s life is finally jeopardized while dangling on the same ledge from which he just watched a cartoon anvil squish a guy. That juxtaposition makes it hard to treat Connor’s endangerment with much gravity. It’s a fun episode when embracing its quirks, such as Lysa battling through the cartoonish finale in clown garb. And The Librarians: The Next Chapter struck gold with Hermione, but her episode feels rushed out at the wrong end of the season without much attention to balance and consistency. Under better circumstances, it really could have been a season standout.
The Librarians: The Next Chapter Episode 11
6/10
Release Date
May 25, 2025
Network
TNT
Showrunner
Dean Devlin
Writers
Dean Devlin
Franchise(s)
The Librarians
Caroline Loncq
Elaine Astalot
Pros & Cons
Fun story premise involving art and magic.
Great new character with an interesting backstory.
Sincerely enjoyable comedic moments.
Winslow's and Hermione's plotlines don't blend well.
Tonal imbalance between darkness and comedy.
Stylistic inconsistencies when bringing paintings to life.
