🚗 USE CODE: JJ20 for a 20% discount on your carVertical check:
https://www.carvertical.deal/27DJQ2C/4Z3MTK/?source_id=INFL&sub1=jj20
*Join Joey and Josh here:*
https://bit.ly/JoinJAndJ
- Videos 48 hours before anyone else
- Members Only Livestreams
How far would someone go to create the perfect alibi?
How far would someone go to create the perfect alibi?
In today's true crime documentary, we investigate the disturbing case of **Stephen McCullagh**, the Irish YouTuber who attempted to use a fake livestream as an alibi after murdering his pregnant girlfriend, **Natalie McNally**.
We break down the complete timeline, from Stephen's early life and disturbing behaviour to his relationship with Natalie, the planning behind the fake YouTube livestream, the police investigation, forensic evidence, CCTV, digital footprint, and the trial of Stephen McCullagh as well as explaining what's happening NOW.
How did investigators discover the livestream wasn't actually live? Why did police initially believe his alibi? What evidence proved what really happened?
If you enjoy true crime podcasts, crime documentaries, murder case breakdowns, criminal psychology, police investigations and documentary-style storytelling, make sure you're subscribed to Joey & Josh for more weekly deep dives.
What do you think was the biggest mistake Stephen McCullagh made during the investigation? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.
00:00 – Who Was Irish YouTuber Stephen McCullagh?
01:48 – Who Was Natalie McNally?
03:59 – How Did Stephen McCullagh Meet Natalie McNally?
08:35 – Were There Early Warning Signs About Stephen?
13:05 – How Did Stephen Hide His Double Life Online?
24:39 – What Mistakes Did Stephen Make Before the Murder?
27:46 – If Stephen Deleted the Evidence, How Did Police Catch Him?
31:23 – Why Was Stephen Allowed to Attend Natalie’s Funeral?
37:14 – What Evidence Finally Proved Stephen Was the Killer?
43:22 – What Sentence Did Stephen McCullagh Receive?
#TrueCrime #CrimeDocumentary #joeyandjosh #TrueCrimePodcast #NatalieMcNally #StevenMcCullagh #MurderCase #PoliceInvestigation #CriminalPsychology #Documentary #CaseBreakdown
If you liked this episode check out our True Crime Playlist!
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLVIeZ2V-r8yoe_tcGNc69P-hzncnQXmkF
*Follow Us*
Tiktok:
https://www.tiktok.com/@joeyandjosh
Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/show/1G0OGok4kkOQYDya50d0ac?si=68842d17117d45c2
Reddit:
https://www.reddit.com/r/JoeyAndJosh/
Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/joeyandjoshpod
Big Thanks To Editor Dan!
Follow him here:
https://www.linkedin.com/in/danieljcurme?utm_source=share_via&utm_content=profile&utm_medium=member_ios 
Comments (0)